European State Systems| Case Study: France, England

In this post, notes of “Unit VI: European State Systems” from “DSC- 2: Rise of Modern west-1” are given which is helpful for the students doing graduation this year.

 1. Introduction to European State Systems

– Definition and Characteristics

The early modern period, from the 16th to the 18th centuries, was a time when political power and governance changed a lot in Europe. During this time, the modern state started to develop, with more centralized power, control over land, and organized systems for administration, law, and military. Here’s a simple overview of how states formed and what they looked like during this time.

  – Overview of state formation and governance in early modern Europe

• Centralization of Power: Rulers in this period worked to concentrate power in their hands, reducing the influence of nobles and local leaders. This change was linked to the end of feudalism and the rise of nation-states.
• Sovereignty: The idea of sovereignty became more important, meaning a state had full control over its territory and people without outside interference. Kings wanted to show their authority, especially during wars and conflicts.
• Bureaucratic Administration: Early modern states started to create organized systems to manage governance. They relied more on civil servants and tax collectors to implement policies and maintain order, moving away from the less formal systems of the medieval period.
• Standing Armies: The creation of standing armies (permanent military forces) was another key feature. These armies were often controlled by the kings, helping them maintain power and protect their territories.

  – Key features of European state systems

• Monarchy and Absolutism: Many states were led by kings who had absolute power. Rulers like Louis XIV of France and Peter the Great of Russia represented this idea, where the monarch had full control over the state’s matters and was often seen as chosen by God.
• Legal Systems and Codification: The growth of the state also led to standard legal systems. Rulers wanted to create laws that applied equally to everyone. For instance, the Code Napoléon later served as a model for other countries.
• Religious Control and the Church: Religion was closely linked to politics. Monarchs tried to control religious institutions to keep their power. The Catholic Church was influential, and many rulers either worked with or against it during conflicts like the Reformation.
• The Rise of Capitalist Economies: Economic changes, especially the growth of capitalism and trade, influenced state systems. Monarchs aimed to boost their economies through policies that controlled trade, which helped centralize government power.

– Evolution and Development

  – Historical context and factors leading to the development of modern states

The growth of modern states was a slow process that took centuries, shaped by various political, economic, and social factors. Here are some main points:

1. Decline of Feudalism:
2. The feudal system that organized power in medieval Europe began to weaken. As kings gained more power, the old local lords became less important.
3. Religious Reformation and Wars:
4. The Protestant Reformation and the Catholic Counter-Reformation changed the political landscape. Religious conflicts, like the Thirty Years’ War, pushed rulers to take more control over religious matters, leading to the idea of state sovereignty recognized in the Treaty of Westphalia.
5. Wars and Conflict:
6. Frequent wars required monarchs to strengthen their military and financial systems, leading to the establishment of standing armies and better tax systems.
7. Rise of Trade and Capitalism:
8. Economic growth and the rise of mercantilism gave monarchs new wealth and encouraged the development of state systems that controlled trade.
9. The Enlightenment:
10. Ideas from the Enlightenment about individual rights and democracy influenced the creation of more modern states. Thinkers like John Locke and Montesquieu argued for limited government and the importance of the consent of the governed.

  – Role of political, economic, and social changes

• Political Changes:

• Monarchical Absolutism: Absolute monarchies grew, allowing kings like Louis XIV to centralize power and reduce the influence of nobles.
• Constitutionalism and Parliamentary Power: In some places, like England, power shifted towards constitutional monarchy and parliamentary authority, especially after events like the English Civil War and the Glorious Revolution.
• Economic Changes:
• The rise of capitalist economies and global trade led governments to adopt policies that supported economic growth. Increased wealth from trade allowed monarchs to build armies and support state-building projects.
• Social Changes:
• Social structures changed as the feudal system weakened. The growth of towns and a more mobile population created a need for organized governance. The Enlightenment also inspired new ideas about government and individual rights, leading to revolutions like the French Revolution.

Conclusion

The development of modern states in Europe was influenced by a mix of political, economic, and social changes that shifted from medieval governance. The centralization of power, the creation of bureaucracies, the rise of capitalism, and Enlightenment ideas all played a role in forming modern nation-states. Some rulers embraced absolute power, while others moved towards more constitutional governance. These changes set the stage for future political revolutions in the 18th and 19th centuries.

 2. Case Study: France

The early modern history of France shows how the country became a strong state with a powerful king. Important events, the role of the monarchy and nobles, and changes in government helped France become one of the strongest countries in Europe by the 17th and 18th centuries. Here’s a closer look at how France formed its state, gained power, and developed an absolute monarchy.

– Historical Background

  – Key events leading to the formation of the French state

Modern France started to take shape through key events and changes in politics over many years. These events were important in making France a unified and strong state.

• The Hundred Years’ War (1337–1453):
• This long war between France and England had a big impact on how France developed. It helped centralize power and changed the balance between the king and the nobles. France won the war, which increased the king’s power, especially after the Treaty of Picquigny in 1475, which brought peace. King Charles VII began to rebuild the kingdom, strengthen royal power, and create a better military.
• The Wars of Religion (1562–1598):
• These civil wars between Catholics and Huguenots (Protestants) were a major crisis for France. The St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre (1572), where many Huguenots were killed, showed the depth of religious conflict. The wars ended with the Edict of Nantes in 1598 by Henry IV, which allowed Protestants to practice their religion freely. This helped stabilize France and led to more central power for the king.
• The Rise of the Bourbon Dynasty (1589):
• The Bourbon family began ruling in 1589 when Henry IV became king. His reign was a turning point for France as he worked to unite the country after the Wars of Religion and make the monarchy stronger. His financial reforms improved the country’s economy and helped centralize power.
• The Fronde (1648–1653):
• The Fronde was a series of civil wars involving nobles during the early reign of Louis XIV. Nobles resisted the king’s efforts to centralize power, especially under Cardinal Mazarin, Louis XIV’s chief minister. The Fronde ultimately failed, making the monarchy stronger and showing its determination to control the nobles.

  – Role of monarchy and nobility

The French monarchy was key in the growth of the state. Over time, the kings worked to gain more power as nobles lost their influence.

• Medieval Monarchy: In medieval France, kings had limited power and often relied on local nobles for support. Feudalism meant that nobles had significant control over their lands.
• Rise of the Bourbon Monarchy: The Bourbon family changed the balance of power. Kings like Henry IV and Louis XIII began to centralize power by reducing noble influence. Henry IV improved the financial system, which helped strengthen royal control.
• Nobility’s Decline in Power: Over time, nobles became more like ceremonial figures, especially with the rise of absolute monarchy. By the time of Louis XIV, they had little political power and mainly took on ceremonial roles at the royal court in Versailles.

– Centralization of Power

  – Development of absolute monarchy

The absolute monarchy in France meant that the king had total control over the government, with no need for approval from others. This system was fully developed under Louis XIV, who is seen as the perfect example of an absolute monarch.

• Divine Right of Kings: The idea of the divine right of kings was important to absolute monarchy. Kings believed their power came from God, making their rule unquestionable. This belief allowed kings like Louis XIV to govern without limits from nobles or the church.
• Louis XIV’s Reign (1643–1715):
• Louis XIV centralized power more than any other king. After the Fronde, he decided never to share power again. He famously said, “L’État, c’est moi” (“I am the state”), showing his belief in his complete authority. Louis XIV controlled all important government areas: military, economy, religion, and law.

  – Key monarchs and their contributions (e.g., Louis XIV)

• Henry IV (1589–1610):
• Henry IV worked to bring stability to France after the Wars of Religion. He issued the Edict of Nantes in 1598, allowing Protestants to have religious freedom, which helped stop the conflict. He also focused on economic reforms, reducing debt and promoting agriculture and industry.
• Louis XIII (1610–1643):
• Louis XIII continued the centralization of power. His reign saw the rise of ministers like Cardinal Richelieu, who weakened noble power and strengthened the monarchy. Richelieu ended Huguenot strongholds and limited noble influence, which helped the monarchy gain absolute control.
• Louis XIV (1643–1715):

• The reign of Louis XIV, known as the Sun King, represented the peak of absolute monarchy. His rule symbolized royal power. He built the Palace of Versailles to show his authority and to control the nobles, forcing them to live there and participate in court life.
• Louis XIV also expanded French territory through wars and set up a professional army. His government became very organized, with royal officials (intendants) managing regions and reporting directly to him.

  – Administrative and bureaucratic reforms

• Creation of a Strong Bureaucracy: Louis XIV created a centralized bureaucracy with intendants—royal officials sent to enforce policies, collect taxes, and maintain order. This reduced noble power and gave the king more direct control.
• Control over the Economy:
• Under Jean-Baptiste Colbert, Louis XIV used mercantilist policies to control trade and industry. Colbert’s reforms included creating state-run industries and regulating foreign trade, which increased France’s wealth and the king’s power. He also set tariffs on imports to protect local industries.
• Royal Courts and Patronage:
• Louis XIV set up a grand court at Versailles, which was a center of politics and a place for nobles to seek the king’s favor. This system kept nobles loyal to the king, as they relied on royal support for their status and wealth.
• Military Control:
• Louis XIV changed the French military by creating a standing army under direct royal control. This allowed the king to lead wars and maintain control over territories.

---

Conclusion

The growth of centralized power in France was a slow process that came to a head during Louis XIV’s reign, which represented absolute monarchy. Events like the Hundred Years’ War, the Wars of Religion, and the Fronde helped the monarchy gain control. Kings like Henry IV and Louis XIII started this process, but it was Louis XIV who perfected it, creating a strong, centralized state with a well-organized government, a professional army, and a grand court at Versailles that showed royal power. Through reforms in administration and control of military and economic policies, the French monarchy built one of the most powerful states in Europe.

– Economic Policies and Trade

  – Development of mercantilism

Mercantilism was the main economic idea that guided France’s economy during Louis XIV‘s rule (1643–1715). It focused on making a nation rich by selling more than it bought, and by gathering gold and silver.

• Jean-Baptiste Colbert: The key person behind France’s mercantilist policies was Jean-Baptiste Colbert, Louis XIV’s finance minister. He wanted to make France self-sufficient and stronger in the world. To do this, he:
  • Supported local industries: Colbert helped French businesses, like textiles and shipbuilding, by giving them money, putting taxes on foreign goods, and offering tax breaks. He wanted to decrease France’s reliance on imports.
  • Controlled trade: Colbert set strict rules for the economy, ensuring that French resources benefited the monarchy. This included creating government-run industries and promoting state monopolies in important areas.
  • Built infrastructure: Colbert invested in canals and roads to improve trade and the movement of goods.

  – Impact on domestic and international trade

• Domestic Trade:

• France aimed to cut down imports and boost local production. This helped some industries, especially textiles, grow but also caused problems. High taxes and rules hurt smaller businesses and led to inefficiencies.
• Colbert’s policies led to heavy taxes on peasants and the middle class to fund the military and royal court, causing discontent among some groups.
• International Trade:

• France worked to become a major player in global trade, aiming to export more than it imported. Colbert encouraged trade with other countries, especially through France’s colonies.
• The French East India Company and French West India Company were created to manage trade with the East Indies and the Americas. France exported textiles, wine, and luxury goods while importing sugar, coffee, and spices, which helped the economy grow.

  – Role of colonial expansion

Colonial expansion was key to Louis XIV’s economic policies. Expanding territories overseas was seen as a way to gain wealth and resources.

• Caribbean and Americas: French colonies in the Caribbean (like Saint-Domingue and Martinique) became important for the economy, producing sugar, coffee, and tobacco. France also established trade routes in North America.
• East India Trade: France tried to compete with the British and Dutch in the Indian Ocean. Though not as successful as the British, French colonies in India and Southeast Asia helped with spice and textile trade.

The colonial empire significantly boosted France’s global trade, supporting Louis XIV’s goals of military strength and wealth.

– Social and Cultural Impact

  – Influence of the state on society and culture

Louis XIV greatly influenced French society and culture, aligning them with his vision of a powerful monarchy.

• Centralization of Power: Louis XIV centralized both political and social power. Nobles were brought to the royal court at Versailles, where they needed to participate in court rituals to keep their status. This system made nobles reliant on the king, strengthening his power.
• Court at Versailles: The Palace of Versailles symbolized Louis XIV’s power. The court was the center of culture, where fashion, art, and behavior were strictly managed. Lavish ceremonies emphasized the king’s importance.

  – Role of religion and the Catholic Church

Religion was important for the legitimacy of Louis XIV’s rule. As a devout Catholic, he believed his authority came from God. The Catholic Church supported this view.

• Revocation of the Edict of Nantes (1685):
  • One of Louis XIV’s controversial actions was revoking the Edict of Nantes, which had allowed religious freedom for French Protestants (Huguenots). By revoking it, he aimed for a unified Catholic France, leading to the persecution of Protestants and a loss of skilled workers.
• Catholicism as a Political Tool:
  • Louis XIV worked closely with the Catholic Church to strengthen his rule. The church supported his authority, while he backed the church’s interests.

  – Cultural achievements and contributions

Louis XIV’s reign saw significant cultural advancements that shaped French culture for years.

• Baroque Art and Architecture: France became a center for Baroque style in art and architecture, known for its grandeur and detail. The Palace of Versailles is a famous example, showcasing royal power and wealth.
• Support for the Arts: Louis XIV supported the arts, promoting French classical theater with playwrights like Molière and Racine. He also encouraged French opera and the Academy of Fine Arts, ensuring France’s cultural influence in Europe.
• Cultural Influence on Europe: The court of Versailles set trends in art and fashion that were copied across Europe. French became the language of diplomacy, and French styles were adopted by other monarchs.
• Science and Enlightenment: Louis XIV’s reign coincided with early Enlightenment ideas, with the Royal Academy of Sciences being established in 1666. He supported scientific work that raised France’s intellectual standing.

---

Conclusion

Louis XIV’s rule greatly affected France’s economic and social systems. His mercantilist policies aimed to strengthen the economy through local production, trade, and colonial growth, making France a leading power in Europe. At the same time, his centralized monarchy shaped society, creating a court culture at Versailles that highlighted royal authority.

Culturally, Louis XIV’s support helped develop the Baroque movement in art and theater, reinforcing France’s cultural dominance. His connection with the Catholic Church and his religious policies, especially the revocation of the Edict of Nantes, strengthened his rule but also caused social issues. Overall, Louis XIV’s reign marked a time of major change, with France becoming a model of absolute power, economic progress, and cultural excellence, leaving a lasting impact on the country.

 3. Case Study: England

The growth of the English state and its political systems shows how constitutional monarchy and parliamentary democracy developed over time. Unlike France, where kings had all the power, England saw changes that limited the monarchy’s control and strengthened parliament. This change was influenced by important events, key documents, and the relationship between the king and parliament.

– Historical Background

  – Key events leading to the formation of the English state

The history of England as a strong state can be understood through major events and shifts in power between the monarchy and other political groups.

• Norman Conquest (1066):
• When William the Conqueror took over England in 1066, he set up a unified state by controlling land and giving it to Norman nobles. This created a feudal system with the king at the top and local lords managing the land.
• Magna Carta (1215):
• A key moment was the signing of the Magna Carta in 1215. King John had to agree to this document because of baron rebellions. It limited the king’s power and gave legal rights to nobles and, eventually, all English people. The Magna Carta began the path to constitutional law in England.
• The English Civil War (1642–1651):
• The fight between King Charles I and Parliament led to the English Civil War. Charles I wanted to rule without Parliament, which angered many. The war ended with his execution and the start of the Commonwealth under Oliver Cromwell, showing a big change from absolute monarchy. The monarchy returned later, but the king’s power was now different.
• Restoration and Glorious Revolution (1660-1688):
• The monarchy came back in 1660 when Charles II returned after the Commonwealth ended. However, tensions with Parliament continued. The Glorious Revolution of 1688 was a major event when James II was removed from power without much violence. He tried to take too much control, and when William of Orange and Mary II became king and queen, it marked the start of constitutional monarchy in England.

  – Role of monarchy and parliament

• Early Monarchy: At first, the monarchy was very powerful after the Norman Conquest, controlling the military, laws, and taxes. However, the Magna Carta started to share some of this power with nobles and the public.
• Power Struggles: The monarchy often fought with the nobility, especially during crises. Over time, Parliament became more powerful, gaining the ability to approve taxes and make laws. The clashes in the 17th century helped lead to a constitutional monarchy.
• Shift Toward Parliamentary Power: By the 17th century, the monarchy could not easily rule without Parliament’s agreement. The English Civil War showed that Parliament was necessary for governance. After the Glorious Revolution, England moved towards a parliamentary democracy with William and Mary accepting the Bill of Rights, which limited royal power even more.

– Political Developments

  – Evolution of constitutional monarchy

The growth of constitutional monarchy in England happened slowly, influenced by important events and documents.

  – Key events and documents (e.g., Magna Carta, Glorious Revolution)

• Magna Carta (1215): The Magna Carta was an early document that limited the king’s power, ensuring he could not tax without noble consent and that free men had legal rights. It was initially meant to calm rebellious barons but became a symbol for constitutional governance.
• Petition of Right (1628): This document further limited King Charles I‘s power by stating he could not tax without Parliament’s consent, imprison without cause, or declare martial law in peace. It was a response to the king’s harsh rule.
• The English Civil War (1642-1651): The war was a result of King Charles I refusing to share power with Parliament. The conflict between Royalists and Roundheads ended with a victory for Parliament and the king’s execution, leading to a brief time without monarchy.
• The Glorious Revolution (1688): This was a peaceful takeover, replacing James II because of his attempts to centralize power. When William of Orange and Mary II took the throne, it marked the start of constitutional monarchy. The Bill of Rights (1689) followed, further limiting the monarchy’s power.
• Bill of Rights (1689): The Bill of Rights was a crucial step in establishing constitutional monarchy. It stated the monarchy could not rule without Parliament’s consent and protected rights like freedom from cruel punishment and the right to a fair trial.

  – Development of parliamentary democracy

• The Role of Parliament: The English Parliament initially included the House of Lords (nobility) and the House of Commons (elected officials). Over the 17th century, Parliament gained more power, especially over taxes and governance.
• The Civil War and Commonwealth: The English Civil War temporarily ended the monarchy and established the Commonwealth. This period showed the importance of parliamentary governance. When the monarchy returned in 1660, Parliament had become the supreme legislative body.
• Political Parties and Parliamentary Sovereignty: The 18th century saw the rise of political parties like the Whigs and Tories. The Whigs supported Parliament’s power, while the Tories favored the monarchy. Parliamentary control grew with the Acts of Union (1707), unifying England and Scotland, and the rise of the prime minister as the government leader.
• The Prime Minister and Cabinet: As the monarchy became more ceremonial, the Prime Minister became the main government leader. The cabinet system developed, where senior ministers ran the government, giving more power to elected officials.

---

Conclusion

The creation of the English state was a slow process shaped by key events and documents that limited the monarchy’s power and promoted Parliament’s authority. From the Magna Carta to the Glorious Revolution, England’s political development led to a constitutional monarchy and the parliamentary democracy we see today.

The evolution of constitutional monarchy in England highlighted the importance of parliamentary control over the monarchy, with significant events including the Petition of Right, the English Civil War, and the Bill of Rights. These milestones marked the shift from absolute monarchy to a system where royal power is limited by laws and the people’s will, represented by Parliament.

– Economic Policies and Trade

  – Development of commercial and industrial economy

In the 16th and 17th centuries, England changed from a feudal economy to a more commercial and industrial economy. This change was driven by global trade, the growth of towns, and better farming methods. During the Tudor and Stuart periods, England started using early capitalist practices, which helped lead to the industrial revolution.

• Trade Expansion: England became more involved in international trade, especially with the New World and Europe. Merchants set up permanent businesses, and trading goods like wool, tobacco, sugar, and spices boosted the economy.
• Growth of Capitalism: As investing in trade and industry became more important, England developed a capitalist economy. Merchants invested in ships and trade routes, while landowners focused on profitable farming, particularly wool, which helped the textile industry grow. The guild system began changing into more modern markets, increasing industrial activity.
• Farming Changes: Farming also improved with new techniques and crops, leading to better harvests and population growth. As farming became more commercialized, England’s economy included rural farming and growing city industries like textiles and mining.

  – Impact on domestic and international trade

England’s growth in trade affected both domestic and international trade through better connections with global markets.

• Domestic Trade: Cities like London, Liverpool, and Bristol became busy markets and ports that helped trade with Europe. Long-distance trade led to the rise of banking and financial institutions, including joint-stock companies, which allowed merchants to combine resources for bigger ventures.
• International Trade: England became active in transatlantic trade, creating routes with the New World. England played a big role in the slave trade, providing labor for plantations in the Americas. English merchants also controlled the triangular trade, moving goods like sugar and tobacco from the Americas to Europe and taking manufactured goods to Africa in exchange for slaves.
• The Navigation Acts: To strengthen England’s mercantilist policies, the Navigation Acts were created in the mid-17th century. These laws required that goods shipped to and from England’s colonies be carried on English ships, making England the center of colonial trade and increasing its wealth.

  – Role of colonial expansion

Colonial expansion was key to England’s economic growth during this time. Colonies provided not just raw materials but also markets for English products.

• The British Empire: By the 17th century, England was rapidly expanding its colonies, especially in the Americas and Asia. Colonies in North America, the Caribbean, and parts of India were important for England’s economy, providing resources like tobacco, sugar, cotton, and furs.
• Trade Monopolies: The English government gave monopolies to companies like the East India Company to control colonial trade, helping establish England’s economic presence in Asia and Africa.
• Economic Impact: Colonial expansion fueled the English economy through profits from plantations and increased demand for goods. This wealth helped build the British banking system, including the Bank of England (1694).

– Social and Cultural Impact

  – Influence of the state on society and culture

The state had a strong effect on English society and culture during the Tudor and Stuart periods. The monarchy sought to strengthen its power and influenced cultural life in various ways:

• Monarchy’s Role: Monarchs like Henry VIII and Elizabeth I shaped society. The Elizabethan era saw a rise in theater, literature, and art due to royal support. The monarchy also drove religious reforms, like the English Reformation, that changed society significantly.
• Social Structure: England had a strict social hierarchy, with the aristocracy at the top, followed by a growing middle class and then peasants. Monarchs controlled society through patronage, rewarding supporters with titles and land, which helped maintain stability but also caused discontent among the poor.

  – Role of religion and the Anglican Church

Religion was crucial in shaping English culture and society, especially after the English Reformation.

• The English Reformation: Under Henry VIII, England separated from the Roman Catholic Church and formed the Church of England (or Anglican Church). This break was mainly due to political reasons but led to major changes in religious and social life, making the Church of England the state religion.
• Protestantism and Anglican Church: The Anglican Church led to religious conflicts, especially during Mary I’s reign, who tried to restore Catholicism. However, Elizabeth I established Protestantism as the foundation of society, influencing literature, art, and theater.
• Puritans and Conflict: The Puritans sought to reform the Church of England and played a significant role in social tensions leading up to the English Civil War.

  – Cultural achievements and contributions

England made significant cultural contributions during this time, especially in literature, theater, and the arts.

• Literature: The Elizabethan era is known as a golden age for English literature, with writers like William Shakespeare creating lasting works and establishing English theater as a respected art form.
• Theater: The Elizabethan theater thrived, with famous theaters like the Globe Theatre. Shakespeare’s works and those of his contemporaries captivated audiences and are still performed today.
• Art and Music: Although influenced by Dutch and Flemish styles, England saw growth in music and portrait painting. Portraits of monarchs like Elizabeth I helped shape public perception.
• Scientific Progress: The Scientific Revolution of the 17th century had a big impact, with figures like Isaac Newton and Francis Bacon helping lay the groundwork for modern science.

---

Conclusion

England’s economic policies in the early modern period were key to its shift from farming to a commercial and industrial economy. The rise of capitalism, increased trade, and colonial expansion helped England become a global economic power.

At the same time, religion, especially the Anglican Church, greatly influenced society and culture. The state’s impact on cultural life led to important achievements in literature, theater, and art that continue to be relevant today. Through political, economic, and cultural changes, England laid the foundations for the modern British state, gaining power on the global stage.