Sulh-i-kul and Akhlaqi Tradition| Vaishnava Bhakti & Shaivite traditions

by

 In this post, notes of “Unit 3: Political and Religious Ideas” from “DSC- 1: History of India -5: c. 1500- 1600s” are given which is helpful for the students doing graduation this year

1. Sulh-i-kul and Akhlaqi Tradition; Ideological Challenges

Sulh-i-kul (Universal Peace)

Sulh-i-kul, which means “universal peace,” was an important idea during the time of Akbar the Great, who ruled the Mughal Empire from 1556 to 1605. This principle encouraged religious tolerance, political harmony, and peaceful living among people of different religions, cultures, and backgrounds within the empire.

What is Sulh-i-kul?

  • Sulh-i-kul is a political and philosophical idea that promotes tolerance and peace among various religious groups. It translates to “peace with all,” meaning that no one religion or ethnic group should be favored over others. The belief behind this idea is that true peace and prosperity come from different communities living together.
  • The concept has roots in earlier Islamic governance and was influenced by thinkers like Ibn Sina (Avicenna) and al-Farabi, who wrote about the importance of tolerance. However, it was Akbar who put this idea into practice in the Mughal Empire, showing his belief in unity and tolerance.

How Akbar Implemented Sulh-i-kul

  • Religious Tolerance:
    • Akbar’s approach to Sulh-i-kul was different from the typical sectarianism of the time. He welcomed all religions, including Hinduism, Islam, Jainism, Christianity, and Zoroastrianism.
    • One of his major reforms was the abolition of the jizya tax in 1564, which was a tax on non-Muslims. This decision showed his commitment to treating all religions equally.
  • Din-i Ilahi:
    • In 1582, Akbar started the Din-i Ilahi (Religion of God), which aimed to blend elements from different religions, including Hinduism and Islam. Although it didn’t last long after his death, it reflected his desire for religious harmony.
    • Akbar also organized debates among scholars from various faiths, showing his dedication to interfaith dialogue.
  • Political and Social Impact:
    • Sulh-i-kul helped stabilize the Mughal Empire by encouraging cooperation among different religious groups, which built loyalty among subjects and promoted social integration.
    • Akbar emphasized justice and fairness, ensuring that people of all religions could live peacefully and be treated equally.

Influence on Mughal Governance and Religion

  • Administrative Changes:
    • Akbar’s Sulh-i-kul policy led to the inclusion of non-Muslims in important positions in his government. Rajput kings and Hindu officials played significant roles in the Mughal administration.
    • These inclusive policies strengthened the Mughal government and encouraged loyalty from various communities.
  • Religious Harmony:
    • The implementation of Sulh-i-kul resulted in a time of relative peace and religious harmony in India, even with its diverse population. Akbar’s rule became more secular, focusing on practical governance rather than strict religious rules.

Akhlaqi Tradition

The Akhlaqi tradition refers to the study of ethics and morality in Islamic thought. The word “Akhlaq” means morality and emphasizes good behavior, personal virtues, and social responsibilities. In the Mughal Empire, Akhlaq was important for guiding rulers and officials in their moral duties.

Understanding Akhlaq (Ethical Philosophy)

  • Akhlaq is a branch of Islamic philosophy that focuses on moral principles and how individuals should act in society, religion, and governance. Its goal is to achieve moral excellence by balancing personal virtues with social responsibilities.
  • The Akhlaq tradition combines teachings from the Quran and Hadith with ideas from earlier Greek philosophers like Aristotle. It emphasizes virtues such as justice, honesty, compassion, generosity, and self-control.
  • Akhlaq also guides rulers on how to behave. It stresses that a ruler’s character is essential for maintaining a stable and harmonious state.

Key Works and Authors in Akhlaqi Literature

  • Nasir al-Din Tusi’s “Akhlaq-i-Nasiri”:
    • A significant work in Akhlaqi literature is Akhlaq-i-Nasiri, written by Nasir al-Din Tusi in the 13th century. It provides guidelines on how to live morally and covers topics like justice and leadership.
    • This book influenced later rulers, including those in the Mughal Empire, shaping their governance and court behavior.
  • Other Important Authors:
    • Ibn Khaldun contributed to Akhlaqi thought by discussing the role of ethics in societies and rulers’ behaviors.
    • In the Mughal context, philosophers like Shah Waliullah Dehlawi also shaped ethical traditions.

Impact on Court Culture and Governance

  • Court Culture:
    • The Akhlaq tradition influenced Mughal court culture, where rulers like Akbar valued personal morality and ethical behavior. Courtiers were expected to embody justice, honesty, and virtue.
    • Akbar and other emperors saw themselves as moral leaders, responsible for just governance.
  • Administrative Philosophy:
    • The Akhlaq philosophy also guided the Mughal administration, affecting decisions on justice and resource distribution.
    • Akbar aimed to build an ethical bureaucracy to support his vision of Sulh-i-kul and promote a fair and tolerant society.

Conclusion

Both Sulh-i-kul and the Akhlaqi tradition were vital in shaping the Mughal Empire’s governance and culture. Akbar’s focus on religious tolerance aimed to create a peaceful empire where different communities could coexist. Meanwhile, the Akhlaq tradition provided the ethical guidelines for rulers and officials, helping to establish a just and stable Mughal state that valued morality and the well-being of all its subjects.

Ideological Challenges

During Akbar’s reign, two important ideas were Sulh-i-kul (Universal Peace) and the Akhlaqi tradition. However, these ideas faced opposition. The Mughal Empire was large and diverse, with many ethnic and religious groups, leading to criticism of Akbar’s reforms from various sources, including those within the Mughal court.

Opposition to Sulh-i-kul and Akhlaqi Ideas

  1. Criticism from Islamic Scholars:
    • Sulh-i-kul, which promoted religious tolerance, was opposed by Islamic conservatives like the ulama (Islamic scholars) and Sufi groups. They believed that treating all religions equally went against the core beliefs of Islam, which prioritizes Islam above other faiths. Some clerics thought Akbar was undermining Islamic law.
    • Akbar’s decision to abolish the jizya tax (a tax on non-Muslims) in 1564 was criticized as it challenged traditional Islamic governance. Critics argued it weakened the protective status of non-Muslims in an Islamic state.
    • Akbar also created Din-i Ilahi, a blend of different religions, which many clerics condemned as a heretical move that strayed from true Islamic practices.
  2. Criticism from Hindu Traditionalists:
    • Some Hindu traditionalists were wary of Din-i Ilahi and Akbar’s efforts to blend religions, seeing it as a threat to traditional Hindu beliefs.
    • Despite Akbar including Hindu Rajputs in his administration, many Hindus felt alienated by the dominant Islamic practices in the Mughal government.

Debates and Discussions in the Mughal Court

  1. Intellectual Activity:
    • Akbar’s court became a lively place for debate on governance, religious tolerance, and morality. He invited scholars and religious leaders from various backgrounds to discuss these topics.
    • The Ibadat Khana (House of Worship) in Fatehpur Sikri was a key venue for these discussions, where people from different religions debated issues like divine authority and the relationship between state and religion.
    • While Akbar aimed for peace among religions, the debates showed tensions, with some Muslim scholars advocating for a stricter interpretation of Islamic principles.
  2. Key Figures:
    • Abul Fazl, a historian and advisor to Akbar, strongly supported Sulh-i-kul and helped promote Akbar’s ideas of religious harmony.
    • Faizi, Akbar’s brother, also supported these reforms and participated in the discussions.
    • In contrast, Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi, an Islamic scholar, criticized Akbar’s policies, arguing that they harmed Islamic values and called for a return to traditional beliefs.

Responses from Later Mughal Rulers

  1. Akbar’s Adjustments:
    • Akbar maintained his policy of religious tolerance but became more cautious after facing criticism. He did not force Din-i Ilahi on his subjects and allowed people to practice their religions freely.
    • Although he continued to support religious tolerance, the formal promotion of Din-i Ilahi faded after his death.
  2. Jahangir’s Approach:
    • Akbar’s son, Jahangir, also faced challenges from religious conservatives. While he leaned more towards Islamic orthodoxy, he upheld some principles of religious tolerance.
    • Jahangir’s policies towards the Sikhs and Jats showed a pragmatic approach, similar to his father’s.
  3. Shah Jahan and Aurangzeb’s Differences:
    • Shah Jahan, Akbar’s grandson, continued some of Akbar’s policies but focused more on centralized governance rather than religious reforms.
    • Aurangzeb, the last major Mughal emperor, took a different path by returning to strict Islamic practices. He reimposed the jizya tax and promoted conservative Islamic laws, leading to increased tensions with Hindus and Sikhs.

Conclusion

The ideological challenges faced by Akbar’s Sulh-i-kul and Akhlaqi traditions illustrate the complex nature of the Mughal Empire. Akbar’s push for religious tolerance faced opposition from both Islamic conservatives and Hindu traditionalists. Debates in the Mughal court highlighted the struggle between conservative Islamic values and Akbar’s inclusive governance. Later rulers like Jahangir, Shah Jahan, and Aurangzeb navigated these tensions differently, but Akbar’s legacy of religious tolerance continued to influence the empire as it evolved.

Vaishnava Bhakti Traditions of North India

The Vaishnava Bhakti traditions in North India are an important religious and cultural movement that started in the 15th century. This movement focuses on devotion to Lord Vishnu and his forms, especially Krishna and Rama, and it significantly influenced Indian society’s religious, social, and cultural aspects.

Introduction to Vaishnavism

Historical Background:

  1. The Bhakti movement was a religious and social change that stressed personal devotion to God, moving away from strict rituals and caste systems. It aimed to make spirituality accessible to everyone.
  2. In North India, the Bhakti movement gained strength during the medieval period, driven by followers of Vishnu, particularly Krishna and Rama. It offered a more personal approach to worship, contrasting with the formal rituals of the Vedic traditions that often required priests.
  3. The rise of Islam in India also influenced the Bhakti movement, promoting a faith that was more individualistic and inclusive, allowing direct communication with God.

Key Figures and Saints:

  1. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu (1486–1534): A major figure in Vaishnava Bhakti, he is viewed as an incarnation of Krishna. He encouraged kirtan (devotional singing) as a way to express love for God. His followers, known as Gaudiya Vaishnavas, spread his teachings widely.
  2. Surdas (1478–1583): A famous poet-saint known for his heartfelt hymns dedicated to Krishna, focusing on his childhood and divine stories. His poetry expresses deep emotions of love and longing for the divine.
  3. Ramanuja (1017–1137): While primarily linked to Sri Vaishnavism, his ideas greatly influenced the Bhakti movement, emphasizing personal devotion to Vishnu and encouraging a direct relationship with God.

Literary and Devotional Practices

Important Texts and Poetry:

  1. Bhagavata Purana: A key text in Vaishnavism, it narrates the life and divine acts of Krishna, emphasizing the importance of bhakti as the highest form of worship.
  2. Works of Tulsidas: A 16th-century poet known for the Ramcharitmanas, which retells the story of Rama. His writings promoted Rama worship and the chanting of his name for spiritual salvation.
  3. Bhakti Poetry of Surdas: Surdas wrote many devotional songs about Krishna, focusing on the love between Krishna and his devotees.

Devotional Practices and Rituals:

  1. Kirtan and Sankirtan: These practices involve singing the names of God, especially Krishna, and are central to Vaishnava devotion, helping devotees connect spiritually.
  2. Temple Worship: Temples dedicated to Krishna and Rama play a vital role, where rituals include singing hymns, offering food, and performing light ceremonies.
  3. Pilgrimages: Devotees visit sacred sites linked to Krishna and Rama, such as Vrindavan, Mathura, Dwarka, and Ayodhya.

Impact on Society and Culture

Influence on Art, Music, and Architecture:

  1. Art: The Bhakti movement greatly influenced Indian art, with popular themes including images of Krishna and Rama in paintings and sculptures.
  2. Music: The devotional music of saints like Surdas and Tulsidas became integral to classical Indian music, focusing on emotional expression and devotion.
  3. Architecture: Many beautiful temples were built during this period, reflecting the devotional spirit of the Bhakti movement.

Role in Social Reform and Community Building:

  1. The Vaishnava Bhakti movement challenged the rigid caste system and emphasized that anyone could reach God through sincere devotion, regardless of their social status.
  2. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu promoted equality among devotees, including those from lower castes and women. His teachings encouraged breaking down social barriers.
  3. Tulsidas emphasized moral values and devotion to Ram, helping unite people from various backgrounds.
  4. The Bhakti movement fostered unity and spiritual equality, creating communities centered around temples and devotional singing.

Conclusion

The Vaishnava Bhakti traditions of North India significantly shaped the region’s religious, social, and cultural life. By focusing on personal devotion to Krishna and Rama, saints like Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, Surdas, and Tulsidas transformed religious practices and challenged social hierarchies. Their contributions to poetry, music, and temple architecture remain central to Indian religious life today. Through their messages of inclusivity and equality, the Vaishnava Bhakti traditions helped create a more unified and egalitarian vision of Indian society.

Shaivite Traditions

Shaivism is a major tradition within Hinduism that focuses on the worship of Shiva as the highest god. It has a long and varied history, influencing not just religious practices but also art, architecture, dance, and literature across India and beyond.

Overview of Shaivism

History and Core Beliefs:

  1. Shaivism is one of the oldest forms of Hindu worship, with roots tracing back to the Indus Valley Civilization, where early representations of Shiva can be found. The tradition began to develop more clearly in the early centuries CE with its unique beliefs and philosophies.
  2. At its heart, Shaivism teaches that Shiva is the ultimate god, responsible for creating, preserving, and destroying the universe. He governs the cycle of birth, death, and rebirth (samsara). Worship of Shiva includes meditation, rituals, and devotion aimed at achieving moksha, or liberation from reincarnation.
  3. Shiva is known for various roles, including being the destroyer of evil, the god of ascetics, and the lord of dance (Nataraja), symbolizing the cosmic cycles of creation and destruction.
  4. Shaivism encourages followers to realize their true self (atman) as one with Shiva through devotion (bhakti), philosophical study (jnana), and ascetic practices (yoga).

Major Sects and Schools of Thought:

  1. Shaiva Siddhanta: A prominent school mainly in Tamil Nadu and Sri Lanka, it teaches that while Shiva is the ultimate god, the soul (atman) is distinct but can unite with Shiva through devotion and righteous living.
  2. Kashmir Shaivism: Developed in Kashmir around the 8th century CE, this school sees Shiva as the absolute reality and teaches that the universe is a manifestation of Shiva’s consciousness. Liberation is achieved through deep meditation and realizing one’s identity with Shiva.
  3. Veerashaivism (or Lingayatism): Founded by the saint Basava in the 12th century CE, this sect emphasizes devotion to Shiva represented by the linga, promoting social equality and personal devotion. Basava wrote Vachanas, devotional poetry in Kannada.
  4. Shakta-Shaivism: This tradition combines elements of Shaktism (worship of the goddess Shakti) with Shaivism, viewing Shiva and Shakti as inseparable.

Key Figures and Texts

Important Saints and Philosophers:

  1. Basava (1105–1167 CE): Founder of the Veerashaiva tradition, he advocated for social equality and the idea that devotion to Shiva transcends social barriers through his Vachanas.
  2. Abhinavagupta (950–1020 CE): A key philosopher from Kashmir, he greatly influenced Kashmir Shaivism with his works, which link art and spirituality and promote a non-dualistic view of reality.
  3. Manikkavacakar (9th century CE): A Tamil saint known for his Tiruvasagam, a collection of hymns praising Shiva, which are still highly regarded in Shaivism.

Important Shaivite Texts:

  1. The Shiva Purana: A key scripture detailing Shiva’s mythology, cosmology, and rituals.
  2. The Agamas: Texts outlining the rituals and philosophies of Shaivism, especially in Kashmir Shaivism and Shaiva Siddhanta.
  3. The Vachanas: Poetic expressions by Basava and other saints focusing on devotion to Shiva and the internal worship of the linga.

Cultural and Social Influence

Impact on Regional Cultures:

  1. Shaivism significantly shaped the cultures of South India, particularly in Tamil Nadu, where Shaivite saints and kings built many temples and promoted religious practices.
  2. Kashmir became a center for Shaivism, blending philosophy, mysticism, and art.
  3. Veerashaivism influenced social structures in Karnataka and Maharashtra, promoting equality and rejecting caste distinctions.

Contributions to Art, Dance, and Literature:

  1. Art: Shaivism inspired numerous temples with intricate sculptures and frescoes depicting Shiva, especially the Nataraja, symbolizing his cosmic dance.
  2. Dance: The imagery of Nataraja plays a central role in classical Indian dance forms, representing the cycle of life and creation.
  3. Literature: Shaivite literature includes devotional poems and philosophical texts that emphasize devotion and the quest for spiritual liberation.

Shaivite Practices and Festivals:

  1. Lingayat Worship: In Veerashaivism, devotees worship the Shiva Linga and often wear a small linga as a sign of devotion.
  2. Mahashivaratri: A major festival where devotees fast, chant, and keep vigil to honor Shiva, often pouring milk and honey over the linga.
  3. Pradosha: A regular observance where devotees fast and worship Shiva, especially on the 13th day of the lunar month.

Conclusion

Shaivite traditions have profoundly influenced religious practices, philosophy, art, and social structures in India. With various sects like Shaiva Siddhanta, Kashmir Shaivism, and Veerashaivism, Shaivism offers diverse spiritual paths. Key figures like Basava, Abhinavagupta, and Manikkavacakar have enriched Shaivism’s philosophical and literary heritage, which continues to resonate in modern Hinduism.


Leave a comment